There has been much in the media, and lots of misinformation circulating about about the link between bats and Covid-19.
Our parent body the Bat Conservation trust (BCT) have produced a article with the Facts about Bats and Covid-19, and an excellent set of frequently asked questions. These FAQ are copied (on 5th May 20) below, and the most up to date version can be found on the BCT website.
They also have an excellent page to help dispel the myths – “What have Bats ever done for us?”, and collaborated on a video – “Don’t blame Bats”
Covid -19 Impact on bat surveys
The BCT have also produced guidance for volunteer Bat surveys in particular those involved with the National Bat Monitoring Program (NBMP), the full details of this guidance are on their website. For the bat group, this means some household groups can individually undertake some of the acoustic NBMP surveys this summers.
On 28th May 2020 Natural England issued COVID-19 guidance from Defra covering field work (including entering bat roosts and handling bats)
For Bat Roost visits and bat handling the BCT have published notes in response to IUCN guidance issued on 12th April 2002 that “the IUCN Bat Specialist Group recommends suspending all field work that involves direct interactions with bats. This includes capture and handling bats, as well as being in sustained proximity (< 3 m) at roost sites“. Detailed guidance to Bat Groups was issued on 19th July 2020 in a Special Edition Bulletin – Bat Group Activities & COVID-19.
On 19th June 2020 the IUCN SSC Bat Specialist group published their updated Recommended Strategy to Reduce the Risk of Transmission of SARS-CoV-2 from Humans to Bats. This states that it is the “opinion of the panel that there is a credible risk of human-to-bat transmission of SARSCoV-2“. Their recommendations look to minimise this risk, and they have produced a MAP Decision Tree for Researchers to help.
For our Bat Group this means we will have to suspend all activities like Bat Box checks, internal roost visits or bat handling (outside of care) for the foreseeable future.
Cavers impacts on BAts, regarding Covid-19
On 22nd August 2020 the IUCN SSC Bat Specialist group published their recommendations to reduce the risk of transmission of SARS-CoV-2 from humans to bats by cavers. In this the IUCN states that “We remind cavers to never touch or handle bats and to maintain general best practices to minimize disturbance to bats, such as … not visiting caves during bat hibernation and breeding seasons..”
Bat Care and Covid-19
Impact of Covid-19 on bat PROFESSIONALS
For Bat professionals the Chartered Institute of Ecology and Environmental Management (CIEEM) have also produced guidance pages on their website, on undertaking bat consultancy work safely.
For a more light-hearted look, the Guardian published this cartoon by First Dog on the Moon entitled: “Should we blame bats for the terrible coronavirus? We should not. Bats are our friends”
BCT FAQ – Bats and Covid-19
The details provided below are based on the best scientific information available at the time of writing (latest update 29/04/20). This page will be reviewed regularly and revised as necessary in light of new information. Research papers about Coronavirus Disease (COVID-19) and the virus that causes it (SARS-CoV-2) are being produced at an unprecedented rate but much remains to be confirmed.
In addition to questions and answers we have included references and/or further reading at the end of the page for more detailed information (references are numbered in the text). We have not included questions on the impact on human health of COVID-19. Please refer to the NHS website (or if you are outside of the UK the relevant health agency in your own country). You may also be interested in BCT’s set of frequently asked questions about bats and diseases and information on the relationship between bats and diseases more generally.
We welcome any comments about the information presented here as well as further questions of your own; please do get in touch.
What is a coronavirus?
Coronaviruses are a large family (the Coronoviridae) of viruses and although they include a small number of very serious respiratory viruses (such as SARS-CoV-2, the virus that is causing the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic) they also include a huge number of other viruses which are not harmful at all. Human specific coronaviruses include one of the causes of the common cold. In fact humans, like many animals such as bats, are associated with a whole range of viruses that are not harmful at all.
Where does COVID-19 come from?
The short answer is that we don’t know for sure yet. Scientists do agree that COVID-19 is caused by a coronavirus from an animal (1,2). COVID-19 is a zoonosis, a human disease of animal origin. However, the animal source of SARS-CoV-2, the virus behind the COVID-19 pandemic, has not yet been confirmed. It is likely to have its origins in a bat species (1,2) but it may have reached humans through an intermediary species (pangolins have been suggested) (3,4), or mutated within humans to be able to be transmitted between people and cause disease (3). This is a priority area for research but it is important to note that subsequent transmission of COVID-19 is from person to person. It is transmission between people that has spread the disease globally.
Do the bats in my house have COVID-19? / Can I get COVID-19 from the bats in my house?
No, the virus that causes COVID-19 hasn’t been isolated from any of the UK’s 17 resident breeding bat species. There are no known zoonotic (harmful to humans) coronaviruses found in UK bats. In fact the COVID-19 virus hasn’t been isolated from any of the world’s 1400+ species of bat. A coronavirus with 96% of its genome in common with SARS-CoV-2 (2) has been found in a single species of bat (Rhinolophus affinis) in China. This may sound significant, but to put it in context, we share 96% of our genome with chimpanzees but we are not the same species. It is important to stress that in this pandemic it is humans that transmit COVID-19 to other humans, not bats.
How did COVID-19 get from wildlife to people?
As with the origins of COVID-19, we don’t know for sure but we have a very good idea of what is likely to have happened. Zoonotic spillover is the transmission of a pathogen from an animal to a human, often through an intermediary species. For such an event to happen, zoonotic pathogens must overcome a series of barriers that would otherwise prevent spillover infections into humans (5). If we fail to care for the natural world and all of the services that it provides to humanity then ecosystems can break down in ways that have significant impacts on us, including through emerging infectious diseases (6).
Human alterations to the environment can therefore break or even remove some of these barriers (7). For example destruction of natural habitat by deforestation and subsequent intensive livestock farming on the cleared land. This process brings wildlife into closer contact with humans and livestock than would naturally happen, providing the opportunity for a spillover event (the end sequence of the 2011 film ‘Contagion’ illustrates this very process) (8).
The live wildlife trade, in which many different species of wild animals are brought together in markets, can also provide the conditions for spillover events. The traded animals are held in cramped, stressful, unsanitary conditions, with many different species caged side by side and slaughtered to order. The species in these markets would not be found together in such close proximity in the wild. Such trade increases the chances that viruses can jump from one species to another, and ultimately from animals to humans. The science writer, David Quammen, who has published two books on wildlife and diseases, wrote about this back in January (9). He argues that we specifically made this pandemic (or epidemic as it was then) by engaging in unsustainable ecological destruction and the dangerous and devastating trafficking and illegal trade of wildlife for human consumption.
BCT has joined with more than 240 other organisations from around the globe to call for the World Health Organisation (WHO) to recommend that governments worldwide ban wildlife markets and the use of wildlife in traditional medicine. You can read the letter to WHO via our News pages.
Why does BCT support the call for all live markets of wild animals to be closed?
Kit Stoner, BCT’s Chief Executive Officer, states “The selling of live wild animals in markets is both cruel and facilitates the spread of viruses by bringing stressed animals of different species into close proximity where this would not naturally occur. Wildlife markets pose an increasing risk to human health and a danger to the conservation of bats and other wildlife. Bat Conservation Trust recognises the need to take urgent action which is why we have joined this broad coalition of organisations demanding governments ban wildlife markets.”
Dr Kevin Olival, of EcoHealth Alliance, points to closing and cleaning up wildlife markets as a win-win solution in a National Geographic article: “One intervention, which is fairly simple, is reducing the wildlife trade and cleaning up the wildlife markets. Cutting back the wildlife trade has a win-win effect of both protecting species that are harvested from the wild and of reducing spillover of new viruses”(10). There is a widespread recognition that along with banning wildlife markets there is a need for initiatives that both educate people and provide those dependent on this type of trade with alternative sources of income and protein in order to further reduce the risk to human health.
Did bats cause the COVID-19 pandemic?
No, the pandemic was caused by people. Human activities that alter the environment can increase the risk of disease spillovers from wildlife to people (a zoonotic spillover is the transmission of a pathogen from an animal to a human). The science writer, David Quammen, who has published two books on wildlife and diseases, wrote about this back in January (9). He argues that we specifically made this pandemic (or epidemic as it was then) by engaging in unsustainable ecological destruction and the dangerous and devastating trafficking and illegal trade of wildlife for human consumption.
Deforestation and subsequent intensive livestock farming on the cleared land will bring wildlife into much closer contact with humans and livestock than would naturally happen, providing the opportunity for a spillover event. Opening up roads through pristine rainforest increases access for hunting. The live wildlife trade, in which many different species of wild animals are brought together in markets provide conditions for spillover events. The traded animals are held in cramped, stressful, unsanitary conditions, with many different species caged side by side and slaughtered to order. The species in these markets would not be found together in such close proximity in the wild. Such trade increases the chances that viruses can jump from one species to another, and ultimately from animals to humans.
Would culling bats stop the disease?
No, culling bats will not end the COVID-19 pandemic or any future emerging infectious disease outbreaks, in fact this may well increase the dangers since stressed animals may become more disease prone. It is human activity that led to the current pandemic and it will be changing human behaviour in relation to wildlife that may prevent future pandemics. To prevent future outbreaks we need to stop uncontrolled habitat destruction and control the trade in wild animals. See ‘How did COVID-19 get from wildlife to people?’ above.
There are over 1,400 bat species around the world (of which 17 are resident and breeding in the UK). Many have adapted to living alongside us in both urban and rural environments, in our gardens, parks and even roosting around our homes, without posing a threat to their human neighbours.
Many bat species are in trouble and need our help to survive. Some bat species have legal protection (all do here in the UK) but globally many don’t and much more needs to be done to ensure the survival of bats and other wildlife around the world. While the killing of bats will not have any effects on the spread of COVID-19, it would adversely affect the conservation of bat populations and the benefits they bring to people and our ecosystems. Bats provide enormous benefits including pollination, seed dispersal and pest control, worth billions of dollars annually. (See the BCT news item ‘What have bats ever done for us’ for more information.)
The Secretariats of the Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals, the Agreement on the Conservation of Populations of European Bats and the Agreement on the Conservation of African-Eurasian Migratory Waterbirds have issued a statement of facts relating to bats and COVID-19.
You say that there are no zoonotic coronaviruses in the UK’s bats, but don’t they carry the rabies virus?
A small number of bats in the UK have been found to carry rabies viruses called European Bat Lyssaviruses (EBLV); but these are from a completely different viral group to the virus that causes COVID-19.
There are two known rabies viruses found in the UK: EBLV-1 and EBLV-2 (these are not the same as the classical rabies virus, which has never been found in a bat in Europe). Rabies caused by infection with EBLV has only been associated with one human case in the UK and EBLVs have only been found in a small number of bats despite more than 15,000 bats having been tested by the Animal & Plant Health Agency since 1986. EBLVs are transmitted via a bite or scratch therefore there is no risk if you do not handle bats. If you do need to handle a bat (i.e. if it is grounded/injured) wear gloves to protect yourself from any potential risk. It is always good practice to wear gloves when handling wild animals anyway (11). For more information please see our web pages about bats and rabies and what to do if you find a grounded bat. No other zoonotic diseases have been found in UK bats.
Do bats carry more diseases that other animals?
No, bats don’t host any more disease-causing (zoonotic) viruses than any other groups of animals (mammals and birds) of similar species diversity (12). There are more than 1,400 different bat species, the second largest group of mammals by species. Taken as a group, bats are considered ‘reservoirs’ (long-term hosts) of a number of viruses but most of these are not harmful and cannot be passed to humans.
What about bat soup, or 5G or secret laboratories?
There is a lot of misinformation circulating around the COVID-19 pandemic. It is really important that people check the facts behind the stories they see in the media or via social media platforms.
There are excellent fact checking websites, including Full Fact UK, Snopes, etc., the COVID-19 specific Misinformation Watch and Coronavirus: the science explained (focussed on human health), and more generally the FAIR website provides guidance on how to detect bias in the news media.
References and further reading
- Wu et al (2020) A new coronavirus associated with human respiratory disease in China. Nature 579, 265-269
- Zhou et al (2020) A pneumonia outbreak associated with a new coronavirus of probable bat origin. Nature 579, 270-273
- Andersen et al (2020) The proximal origin of SARS-CoV-2. Nature Medicine 26, 450–452
- Lam et al (2020) Identifying SARS-CoV-2 related coronaviruses in Malayan pangolins. Nature (pre-publication).
- Plowright et al (2017) Pathways to zoonotic spillover. Nature Reviews Microbiology 15, 502–510
- Robins (2012) The Ecology of Disease. The New York Times
- Contagion. Steven Soderbergh. Warner Brothers. 2011
- Lindahl & Grace (2015) The consequences of human actions on risks for infectious diseases: a review. Infection Ecology & Epidemiology 5, 1
- Quammen (2020) We Made the Coronavirus Epidemic. The New York Times
- Akpan (2020) New coronavirus can spread between humans—but it started in a wildlife market. National Geographic
- RSPCA (2020) What to do with injured animals.
- Mollentze & Streicker (2020) Viral zoonotic risk is homogenous among taxonomic orders of mammalian and avian reservoir hosts. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences